Follow-Up Email Sequence
A follow-up email sequence for re-engaging non-responsive link building prospects
For SEO Manager
Follow-Up Sequence for Non-Responders
Use this sequence when your initial outreach gets no response. Each follow-up adds new value rather than simply asking again.
The emails are written out as an illustrative example: Alex from a fictional analytics site, Brightpath, following up with Jordan at a fictional SEO blog, Harbor Digital. Names, pages and content are invented; replace them with your own.
Follow-Up 1: The Gentle Bump (3-4 Days After Initial Email)
Subject: Re: Quick question about your local SEO checklist
Hi Jordan,
Just bumping this up in case it got buried. I think a link exchange between our rank tracking guide and your local SEO checklist could work really well for both of our audiences.
Happy to go into more detail if you are interested.
Alex
Follow-Up 2: The New Angle (7-8 Days After Initial Email)
Subject: Another idea for Harbor Digital
Hi Jordan,
I wanted to share another angle that might interest you. We just published a guide to tracking calls from Google Business Profile listings. It covers call tracking numbers, UTM tags and reporting, and could complement your article on local SEO for service businesses.
Would you be open to exploring a reciprocal link between our content?
Alex
Follow-Up 3: The Soft Close (14 Days After Initial Email)
Subject: Should I close the loop?
Hi Jordan,
I have reached out a couple of times about a potential link collaboration between our sites. I completely understand if the timing is not right or it is not a fit.
If you would prefer I not follow up, just let me know and I will remove you from my list. Otherwise, I am happy to chat whenever it makes sense.
All the best with Harbor Digital.
Alex
Timing Tips
| Day | Best Send Time | |
|---|---|---|
| Follow-Up 1 | Day 3-4 | Morning (9-10am) |
| Follow-Up 2 | Day 7-8 | Afternoon (1-2pm) |
| Follow-Up 3 | Day 14 | Morning (10-11am) |
Rules
- Never send more than 3 follow-ups
- Stop immediately if they ask you to
- Vary send times from the original email
- Each follow-up should add new information or a new angle